| Won By: | Won From: | Date: | Event: | Length of Reign: |
| Titan | Vacant
(Defeated War in Tournament Finals.) |
3/28/99 | March Madness: 1999 | 15 Days |
| Psycho | Titan | 4/12/99 | Monday Night Mayhem | 13 Days |
| Ravager | Psycho | 4/25/99 | April Annihilation: 1999 | 15 Days |
| Darren McCarty | Ravager/Kid Korn/Deep Chill | 5/10/99 | Monday Night Mayhem | 7 Days |
| Ravager [2] | Darren McCarty | 5/17/99 | Monday Night Mayhem | 4 Days |
| Titan [2] | Ravager/War/Deep Chill | 5/21/99 | Friday Night Superstars | 16 Days |
| The Phantom (*1) | Titan | 6/6/99 | Vengeance: 1999 | 5 Days |
*1- President Ryan Lenz strips The Phantom of the belt due to failure to properly defend it. A tournament is scheduled.